No, No and Thrice, No

Quest Giver Mary-Beth Gaskill
Region Shady Belle, Bayou Nwa
Reqs The Joys of Civilization
Reward Tilly Jackson

No, No and Thrice, No is a Story Mission in Red Dead Redemption 2 (RDR2). This is one of the "Main Quests" of the game and players must complete it to advance the Story. Completing Story Missions opens up Stranger Missions as well as additional content throughout the game.


No, No and Thrice, No Mission Details

Susan and Arthur head to the Foreman Brothers' hideout to rescue Tilly, who has been kidnapped.



No, No and Thrice, No Objectives

  • Kill both of the Foreman boys yourself during the chase
  • Complete with at least 90% accuracy



No, No and Thrice, No Related Characters



No, No and Thrice, No Walkthrough


Day Dreams Interrupted

Arthur Morgan (you) speaks to Mary-Beth Gaskill at the camp. She tells a bit about her past before asking you about your first encounter with Mary Linton. Before you can both get too much into your conversation, Susan Grimshaw storms towards you and tells you she requires your help in rescuing Tilly Jackson, as she's been kidnapped by the Foreman Brothers. You hop onto a wagon and ride out with Ms. Grimshaw.


Gritty Grimshaw

As you ride out, Grimshaw fills you in on the reason behind Tilly's disappearance also points out that Kieran Duffy has been missing for a while as well, and that she'd get a search team out to find him. When you arrive at the house, Ms. Grimshaw will talk to the guard momentarily before killing him with her knife. She then tells you to proceed into the house to find Tilly. Enter through the front door, and there will be a Foreman Brother -kill him. Then you'll find Tilly tied up and guarded by another Foreman, through the door on the left. Once you've killed him, free her and then give chase to the rest of the Foreman Brothers who ride off on their horses.

Ms. Grimshaw will mount the back of your horse as you go to take care of the final three Foreman Brothers who rode away. Kill the first two, then Lasso the third one. When you've done this, Ms. Grimshaw will take one of the dead men's horses back, allowing you to stow Anthony Foreman on the back of your horse. Bring him back to Tilly where after some talking, it is down to you to either kill him or spare him.

Whatever your decision may be, will complete the mission.



Notes & Tips

  • ??
  • ?? 


Story Missions
A Fine Night of Debauchery  ♦  A Fisher of Men  ♦  A Fork in the Road  ♦  A Kind and Benevolent Despot  ♦  A New Future Imagined  ♦  A New Jerusalem  ♦  A Quick Favor for an Old Friend  ♦  A Quiet Time  ♦  A Rage Unleashed  ♦  A Really Big Bastard  ♦  A Short Walk in a Pretty Town  ♦  A Strange Kindness  ♦  Advertising, the New American Art – II  ♦  American Distillation  ♦  American Fathers – II  ♦  American Venom  ♦  Americans at Rest  ♦  An American Pastoral Scene  ♦  An Honest Day's Labors  ♦  An Honest Mistake  ♦  Angelo Bronte, a Man of Honor  ♦  Archeology for Beginners  ♦  Banking, the Old American Art  ♦  Bare Knuckles Friendships  ♦  Blessed are the Meek?  ♦  Blessed are the Peacemakers  ♦  Blood Feuds, Ancient and Modern  ♦  Brothers and Sisters, One and All  ♦  Country Pursuits  ♦  Dear Uncle Tacitus  ♦  Do Not Seek Absolution – I  ♦  Do Not Seek Absolution – II  ♦  Eastward Bound  ♦  Enter, Pursued by a Memory  ♦  Exit Pursued by a Bruised Ego  ♦  Farming, for Beginners  ♦  Fatherhood and Other Dreams – II  ♦  Fatherhood, for Beginners  ♦  Fatherhood, for Idiots  ♦  Favored Sons  ♦  Fleeting Joy  ♦  Friends in Very Low Places  ♦  Further Questions of Female Suffrage  ♦  Gainful Employment  ♦  Good, Honest, Snake Oil  ♦  Goodbye, Dear Friend  ♦  Hell Hath No Fury  ♦  Help a Brother Out  ♦  Home Improvement for Beginners  ♦  Home of the Gentry?  ♦  Honor, Amongst Thieves  ♦  Horse Flesh for Dinner  ♦  Horsemen, Apocalypse  ♦  Icarus and Friends  ♦  Jim Milton Rides, Again?  ♦  Just a Social Call  ♦  Magicians for Sport  ♦  Money Lending and Other Sins – III  ♦  Motherhood  ♦  Mrs. Sadie Adler, Widow – II  ♦  My Last Boy  ♦  Old Friends  ♦  Old Habits  ♦  Our Best Selves  ♦  Outlaws from the West  ♦  Paradise Mercifully Departed  ♦  Paying a Social Call  ♦  Polite Society, Valentine Style  ♦  Pouring Forth Oil – II  ♦  Pouring Forth Oil – IV  ♦  Preaching Forgiveness as He went  ♦  Red Dead Redemption  ♦  Revenge is a Dish Best Eaten  ♦  Savagery Unleashed  ♦  Simple Pleasures  ♦  Sodom? Back to Gomorrah  ♦  That's Murfee Country  ♦  The Aftermath of Genesis  ♦  The Battle of Shady Belle  ♦  The Bridge to Nowhere  ♦  The Course of True Love – II  ♦  The Course of True Love – III  ♦  The Course of True Love – V  ♦  The Delights of Van Horn  ♦  The Fine Art of Conversation  ♦  The Fine Joys of Tobacco  ♦  The First Shall Be Last  ♦  The Gilded Cage  ♦  The Joys of Civilization  ♦  The King's Son  ♦  The New South  ♦  The Sheep and the Goats  ♦  The Spines of America  ♦  The Tool Box  ♦  The Wheel  ♦  Trying Again  ♦  Uncle's Bad Day  ♦  Urban Pleasures  ♦  Visiting Hours  ♦  We Loved Once and True – III  ♦  Welcome to the New World  ♦  Who is Not without Sin  ♦  Who the Hell is Leviticus Cornwall  ♦  Who the Hell is Leviticus Cornwall?

Join the page discussion Tired of anon posting? Register!

Load more
⇈ ⇈